Among current American authors, Richard Powers is one who does not really need artificial intelligence (AI) to advance his craft. He is so smart and his fund of knowledge is so vast that one is left wondering whether his brain is structured and functions differently, that he has a mental operating system that is wired unlike the rest of us mortals. The MacArthur Foundation certainly got it right when they granted him a “Genius” award. From his earliest novels like The Goldbug Variations to his recent works, The Overstory and Bewilderment, Powers pulls philosophical ideas and precise scientific details effortlessly into his novels. At times, it can be exhausting, even off putting. But when he succeeds, it is enchanting and as a reader it feels as if you are being drawn into a different realm.
I am glad to report that Playground is a success on this count. In this most recent novel, Powers turns to the ocean as a backdrop for his story. He weaves together the narratives of three main characters. Todd Keane, who is the son of a successful businessman, grows up privileged in upper-crust Chicago. As a high school student in a top-tier private school in the 1970s, he is captivated by the relatively crude computers of the time, mounts the technology wave and feverishly rides it to professional success as an adult. Evie Beaulieu is literally and figuratively thrown into the water at a young age by her father, a deep sea explorer, and becomes obsessed with everything watery. She is more comfortable swimming deep beneath the ocean surface than walking on land. With the support of a gentle and self-effacing husband, she becomes a world famous oceanographer who achieves renown because of her ability to convey the magic and mystery of the ocean equally well to her scientific colleagues and young adult readers, echoes of Richard Powers himself. Finally, Ina Aroita grew up on the Pacific island, Makatea, but moved to the United States to pursue studies in the creative arts and becomes a sculptor. In college, she meets Todd and through him she is introduced to an important fourth character, Rafi Young, who pulls together the Keane-Aroita story lines.
Rafi grew up in the Black neighborhoods of South Side Chicago. He is a voracious reader from the first day of school and, defying the odds, wins a scholarship to attend the same high school as Todd Keane. They meet over intense games of chess, advance to the ancient addictive game of Go, and develop a powerful but vulnerable friendship. They both choose to go to college at the University of Illinois, and Ina is drawn into their orbit. Powers pulls all of these characters into a tight web that centers on the ambitious plan of an American company to build a self-sustaining city that will launched from Makatea and will be submerged under the surface of the water. The residents of the island are being asked to weigh the pros and cons of the “seasteading” initiative and decide whether to approve it. The rationale offered by the proponents is that life in such a unique environment will enable the occupants of the submerged city to live in a realm outside the jurisdiction of any company and be free to pursue their intellectual pursuits and dreams about expanding the use of artificial intelligence, free of government interference and restrictions.
Extreme libertarianism meets AI wonderland.
Powers populates his literary world with characters we come to know well and grow attached to. It is a strength of Playground that they are believable and not simply spokespeople for a point of view. Powers explores many themes in this book. Games, those that people play casually for leisure, like chess, and those that they play intensely for success in life figure prominently in the novel. Todd and Rafi’s obsession with the ancient board game of Go, with its infinite number of possible outcomes branching out from a simple 19×19 linear grid, becomes an incubator for their ideas about computing capacity. Go provides an alluring framework to explore human behavior and model it for use by programmers of life-like computer surrogates. The game provides the initial inspiration for Todd to design powerful AI systems that can mimic humans and beat them at their own games. There is an appreciation of the growing potential for unpredictable outcomes as computer systems become more complex, machine learning diversifies, and neural networks become denser. The example that most impresses Keane (and Powers) involves the game of AlphaGo, an actual computer program, which was designed to play Go at championship level. Todd recounts his feelings of awe when the program made an inexplicable move in a game against Ke Jie, the number one ranked player in the world at the time, that sealed the computer’s victory in a three-game match. This was something that was thought to be beyond the power of any computer (this same episode features prominently in the book Maniac by Benjamin Labatut).
In this novel, the inventiveness of nature and the unpredictability of human interactions far surpasses anything that AI accomplishes. The complexity of the natural world, its wondrous diversity, its unexpected vitality, is captured in incandescent prose as Powers describes the glowing colors of the deep-sea creatures. Can and will computers achieve a sense of stewardship and legacy? Will they develop an attachment to the environment around them and struggle to sustain it and pass it on whole to the next generation of computers in the same way that links people across and with future generations?
The novel reaches a climax and the ending involves an unexpected plot twist. The book is too much of a fun read for me to reveal it and spoil it for you. One hint — keep in mind that Todd Keane is an extraordinarily complex person. That said, what is striking is how marginally AI actually influences the actual outcome of the novel. It is more of a gadget play than an active player in the narrative. It is as if Powers himself is unsure how AI will impact those of us alive today and the generations that will come after us. If this is true for Powers, then it suggests that all of us should stay modest in our predictions of the future of AI. Reading Playground, I think he would remind us to keep in mind that however things turn out with AI, it will probably work out best if we remember the grandeur of nature and the human capacity to care deeply for one another and our environment, qualities that Powers describes with an expansive intelligence and poetic beauty.
Playground
Richard Powers
W. W. Norton & Co.2024.
381 pp (paperback)
Web image by Medhum.org
