Zauner was 25 when her mother was diagnosed with an aggressive, late-stage, mid-life cancer. Zauner was a rebellious child, resentful of Umma’s version of tough love. Growing up the lone Asian student in her Oregon community, she felt both othered at school and an outsider among her mother’s Seoul relatives when she visited them each summer. Just as she was beginning to appreciate her Korean heritage and understand her mother’s love, she learned about Umma’s diagnosis.   

The first half of the memoir exuberantly brings to life scenes from Zauner’s childhood and her brief post-college years as a musician in New York City. Surprisingly, without hesitation, she paused her makeshift career and flew west to care intensively for her mother. Attempting to heroically save Umma, Zauner zealously learned to prepare the native foods they shared. “I would radiate joy and positivity,” Zauner pledged. “I would learn to cook for her—all the things she loved to eat, and I would single-handedly keep her from withering away” (69). Her optimistic culinary efforts produce a poetry of exacting descriptions of the flavors and textures and preparation of those foods. It’s grimly ironic that the chemotherapy her mother endured wiped out her ability to taste or digest Zauner’s loving offerings of health.  

The second half turns from living with Umma to living without her. Wishing to sustain her bond with her mother as Zauner grieved, she continued preparing her Korean family’s recipes. Walking down H Mart’s redolent aisles released “waves” of sorrow that mark the enduring ebb and flow of her grief. Unsuccessful with conventional therapy, she found cooking the best form of self-care: “Every dish I cooked exhumed a memory. Every scent and taste brought me back for a moment to an unravaged home. Knife-cut noodles in chicken broth took me back to lunch at Myeong Dong Gyoja . . . The kalguksu so dense from the rich beef stock and starchy noodles it was nearly gelatinous. My mother ordering more and more refills of their famously garlic-heavy kimchi” (212-213). An image of abundance in the midst of loss.

Zauner’s detailed descriptions of cooking and consuming invite readers to her table, reminding us—as previous celebrated writers have—of the power of the senses to evoke memory and the power of food to strengthen human bonds. Food also powers Zauner’s self-understanding and the unexpected transformational love for her mother: “The culture we shared was active, effervescent in my gut and in my genes, and I had to seize it, foster it so it did not die in me . . . If I could not be with my mother, I would be her” (223-224).  

Zauner’s writing is itself active and effervescent. Through her grief, she holds a steady, unflinching gaze on cancer and death. As she writes candidly about her family, Zauner is critically reflective about her own life. Her writerly achievement is the immediacy of her felt experiences, her grief and her joys made palpable. “Let me feel this,” she courageously writes, dismissing her Korean family’s admonitions to withhold tears (202). An unforgettable image of the process of loving transformation that Zauner experienced unfolds in her description of making the Korean staple kimchee. It is a slow, exacting process of fermenting cabbage that at first strikes her as “controlled death” because “[l]eft alone, a head of cabbage molds and decomposes. It becomes rotten, inedible. But when brined and stored, the course of its decay is altered. Sugars are broken down to produce lactic acid, which protects it from spoiling. Carbon dioxide is released and the brine acidifies. It ages. Its color and texture transmute. It exists in time and transforms. So it is not quite controlled death, because it enjoys a new life altogether” (223). 

As if miraculously, a few years after Umma died, Zauner’s itinerant music career took on a new life. The band she has fronted, Japanese Breakfast, recorded the album Psychopop with a song she wrote about her mother, “In Heaven.” Then they toured the U.S. and South Korea. Although her mother was skeptical about a musical career, Zauner imagined that Umma would be “glad that I had finally found a place where I belonged” (233). 

Crying in H Mart: A Memoir
Michelle Zauner

Publisher Alfred A Knopf
Place Published New York
Edition 2021
Page Count 239

Web photo by Portuguese Gravit

Realizing he was a member of a tangled (a favorite word of the author) group of transsexuals, James felt himself trapped in a conundrum of gender (he felt and considered himself female) versus sex (he was genotypically and phenotypically male). “To me gender is not physical at all but is altogether insubstantial; it is soul, perhaps, it is talent it is the essentialness of oneself” (p.25).  

After some fruitless interactions with the medical profession, Morris travels to Casablanca in the summer of 1972 to undergo sex-changing surgery and becomes Jan Morris. Unlike many if not most transsexuals, post-operatively Morris fared quite well emotionally and was quite happy with the change.  

Jan Morris’s writing is as humorous and eloquent as James Morris’s was. She describes how magazines like Rolling Stone, publishers like Random House, and thousands of readers have never cared what gender or sex was holding the pen; how life changed in clubs, restaurants, and in taxicabs, where Jan met the first man to kiss her, post surgery, “in a carnal way” (p.151). Morris records that “all I did was blush.” 

As the chronicle of one sensitive and highly literate man’s journey from manhood to womanhood, Conundrum offers much commentary on the states of mind of a transsexual, a highly polished writer undergoing the humoral, mental, emotional, and cultural changes of such surgery.  

Prior to surgery, Morris writes about feeling deprived of an identity: “I realize now that the chief cause of my disquiet was the fact that I had none. I was not to others what I was to myself. I did not conform to the dictionary’s definition–‘itself and not something else’ ” (p.40-41). All Morris wanted “was liberation, or reconciliation–to live as myself, to clothe myself in a more proper body, and achieve Identity at last” (p.104). It took courage but it was worth it and Conundrum reads like nothing more, and nothing less, than a successful odyssey of the sexual soul. 

Jan Morris died in 2020, aged 94. 

Jan Morris: Journalist, Historian, ‘Writer About Place’ – Faculty of English

Conundrum
Jan Morris 
New York Review of Books Classics, paperback 2006: 176 pages 
Originally published by Faber and Faber, London, 1974 

Web image by medhum

At age nine, first misdiagnosed and finally identified as having facial bone cancer (Ewing’s sarcoma), Lucy underwent several surgeries and more than two years of intensive chemotherapy and radiation treatments. Pain and nausea, anxiety and fear of more pain and nausea were only part of the ordeal. The young Lucy became aware of what it is to be severely, chronically ill. Her sisters behaved differently toward her: they were polite. “Suddenly I understood the term visiting. I was in one place, they were in another, and they were only pausing.” Even her father felt uncomfortable at her hospital bedside, and Lucy was relieved that he came infrequently.

But being at home was worse: in the hospital the other patients and the staff expected little from her and she felt no guilt or shame; amidst her family, she blamed herself for the tension, arguments over money, and her mother’s depression, even though these elements had existed prior to her illness. Her hair fell out and she became dimly aware that people were staring at her face. Nevertheless, “I . . . was naturally adept at protecting myself from the hurt of their insults and felt a vague superiority . . . . “

Well enough to return to school, Lucy’s disfigured face drew taunts from classmates; she understood finally that she was perceived as ugly and that she would not be loved. Only on Halloween, when she could mask her face, did she feel free and joyful, unconcerned about her appearance, “normal.” Her moods now alternated between despair, determination, and escapism. She became convinced that only facial reconstruction and a restored appearance would make life bearable.

During years of reconstructive surgery Lucy evolved complex rationalizations to give meaning to her suffering. Two anchors had stabilized her existence throughout the misery: a passionate adolescent love of horses, and an adult love of poetry. Eventually outward appearance and inner life became harmonious. “The journey back to my face was a long one.”

Unfortunately, Lucy’s story does not end here. At age 39 she committed suicide. Soon after, her close friend, writer Ann Patchett, wrote a book about their friendship, Truth & Beauty: A Friendship, published in 2003 (HarperPerennial).

Lucy Grealy Interview in 1994 (20 Min.)

Autobiography of a Face
Lucy Grealy
Houghton Mifflin 1994 Boston: 256 pages

1995 Whiting Award Winner in Nonfiction , Poetry: https://www.whiting.org/awards/winners/lucy-grealy
Web image generated from the book cover by Medhum.

Apollo On Call

In this episode of Apollo on Call, Dave is joined by Luki Danukarjanto to discuss Atul Gawande’s book on end-of-life care, as well as relate it to their aging parents and their own experience getting older. They also examine the medical perspective to the situation is well-being or survival the goal of end-of-life care?

Check out Dave’s Substack for more! https://davidmhsu.substack.com/

Web image by Age Cymru 

Additional Episodes

How Real is the Pitt? 

05.05.25 1911

Dr. Stuart Harman joins Apollo On Call to explore The PITT—a gripping medical drama through…

The Remarkable Life of Ibelin

04.17.25 1717

A poignant documentary exploring how a young man with muscular dystrophy found profound connection and…

The Tennis Partner by Abraham Verghese

06.10.25 2919

A special podcast episode blending sports and medicine, exploring The Tennis Partner and the complexities…

Being Mortal by Atul Gawande

03.30.26 516

A thoughtful conversation on aging, mortality, and balancing quality of life with survival in care…

The Emperor of All Maladies by Siddhartha Mukherjee

03.14.25 3199

Two book lovers dive into The Emperor of All Maladies, exploring its impact on medicine…

The collection opens with a poem, “Dedication” (p.1), dedicating the poems that follow to those “dear friends” who share, and so understand, the sufferings of ongoing illness. The implication is that healthy people cannot, yet, truly enter that world and, in fact, “fear” those who must live there. Yet Silver’s poems are a way into that universe. Tender and fierce, the poems in this collection seem to arise fully formed from the deepest part of Silver’s existence. The poems in section I present us with the harsh realities of illness and the anticipation of loss. In the acknowledgements, (p.72), the author notes that the poems in this section are “in honor of my sisters with inflammatory and advanced breast cancer.” In “Advent, First Frost,” she likens that “feathered prophecy” to “a bowl of frozen tears” (p.6) and in “Stage IV,” she writes that she is “taboo, now,” that she and others use words that once embarrassed them, “courage, prayer, miracle.” Even so, she is aware that “Our passports have been stamped– / our wrists and collar bones have been marked” (p.7). In a lovely prose poem on page 11, she writes in memory of her friend, Susan: “Ulysses will sail the storms till he dies. And so, my dear ones, will we” (p.11), combining, as she often does, the reality of approaching death with hope, dignity, and strength. In “Leaving the Hospital” (p.23) and “On a Line from Virginia Woolf’s Diary,” Silver celebrates the return, even if temporary, to life: “And the day takes my body back simply, / the way a mother dresses her child” (p.14). For me, the most moving poem in this section is the title poem, “I Watched You Disappear” (p. 22-23). It is a litany of regret, loss, anger, and pain, related not in poetic images but in plain and deeply human language: “I hate spring, its prettiness. / Your heart kept beating. Why didn’t it just stop?” 

Section II consists of seven, short one-stanza poems based on images from Grimms’ fairy tales. It seems that the first two lines of each poem serve as metaphorical statements about the realities of advanced breast cancer. “Owl Maiden” begins “No transformation’s instant. / Her hair fell out first, replaced by quills” (p.29). “Strawberries in Snow” begins “Belief comes easily to the ill. / Miracles fall from their lips like gems” (p.31). And “The Flowered Skull” offers these opening lines: “The magician finds them, young or old, / mothers, maidens–to him–no matter–” (p.34). The final poem in this section is a tale told to her son, Noah. In “The Hazel Tree,” Silver is the mother who “died and grew into a tree,” “each nut a word she’d grown to tell her son / now that her speaking human voice was gone” (p.35).  

In Section III, she turns, as she did in her first collection, to poems about her family. She visits again the (actual) doors of her life (“Doors” p.39), expresses regret at being impatient with her son, “Ubi Caritas Deus Ibi Est” (p.41), and in other poems examines moments of her family life, especially those shared with her son, father, sister, and husband. This section’s poems rarely mention illness, yet as they share family stories, they hint at the inevitability of loss. The final poem in this section, “Sea Glass,” ends with lines that could be applied as well to the way poems might be born from the wages of a life: “Something salvaged, sunlit, / gem-like. Something saved / from the grinding into grit” (p.55).  

Section IV, like section II, contains only seven poems, three of them commentaries on paintings and, through those commentaries, observations on illness and suffering as well. “Late Renoir” speaks of how the artist painted to “smudge away doubt” and to submerge “the mutilations of war, his dead wife, / the black he banished from his palette” (p.59). The long poem “Valentine Gode-Darel (1873-1915)” is a reflection on the five paintings by Ferdinand Hodler that captured his lover’s sickness, decline, and death (p.60). “Portraits in the Country,” (page 63), offers a glimpse into the poet’s resignation and acceptance of death, a mindset supported by her faith in both the human and the holy: “But I will not rush to put down my sash. / Instead, I will turn the leaf of my book. See with what gentle gravity God / lets it hover, in balance, then fall to its side.” The book’s last poem, “The Firebird,” suggests that words, especially poems, might hold truths that sound louder than the approach of death: “The bell ringing in your throat will drown / out the train’s slow grieving” (p.67). 

These poems are beautifully crafted, often primal, and they touch the deepest reaches of personal illness and the shadow of mortality. Readers who have breast cancer or who have family or friends living with breast cancer, might find these poems difficult to read–others under the same circumstances might find them difficult and yet, at the same time, essential. For me, dealing with the reality of an aggressive breast cancer afflicting someone I love, these poems provide a window into an experience I can only observe from a distance, even if that distance is only an embrace away. These poems provide a portal into the emotions, fears, regrets, and pleas that might be hiding behind a patient’s or a loved one’s exterior of cheerful optimism and determination. We can’t walk the path that a woman with advanced breast cancer is traveling. But these poems help us be companions on the way. 

Miscellaneous 
“Strawberries in Snow” was first published in the Bellevue Literary Review (V12N1).  

Publisher Louisiana State University Press 
Place Published Baton Rouge 
Edition 2014 
Page Count 73 

A previous version of this review was published in the NYU Literature, Arts, and Medicine Database .  
Web image created by Medhum.org

In her second collection, “I Watched You Disappear” Silver’s poems invited us to accompany her on her journey through treatment, anger, despair, determination, and faith. This third collection (her penultimate) continues the author’s beautifully written illness narrative, again presenting moments of joy and of despair, and always of hope. 

Silver places her title poem, “From Nothing” (pg. 1), before Section I as an epigraph to the entire collection. “Each death I witness makes me more my own,” she writes, and although the poem sees “muscle shredded” and “bone sheared,” the poem’s last lines lift, as do many of Silver’s poems, into hope and faith: “and my molecules will vault, emerging. / From darkening days, the light will surge and flee.” Section I begins with poems of memory–“Summers in Vermont” with her family (pg. 5)–and “Coincidence,” when her sister’s child is born on the same day that Silver holds her breath and presses her “shorn chest” to an X-ray machine (pg. 7). The memories here are of family moments, both the joyful and those tinged with such “darkening days.” In “Luzerne,” she recalls when time was “consigning” her to such darkness, but two things saved her: her son, the poet’s hand touching his “damp blond hair,” and poetry, “offering itself like a pair of velvet shoes” (pg.13). Silver develops the idea of poetry as a special entity, a gift that enables her to walk forward in her journey, in “Raven” (pg. 15). She imagines a raven lifting her, holding her, and then setting her down in her home, where, she says, “dawn drove a pen into my hand.” This sense of urgency and necessity pervades all of Silver’s poems, as if she has been commanded to write her story.  

Section II begins in “Anguish” (pg. 19) a stunning poem about the loss of her first child, a daughter, but the section ends in joy with “After a Favorable PET Scan” (pg. 38). It might be difficult to find another poem by any author that offers such resounding relief and happiness. This poem, especially, speaks to how terrible every test is for those who are suffering, for those whose test results might mean more medication, more surgery, or less time to live. The celebratory release felt by patients when results bring good news must be a special kind of joy: “Oh world, I will give you all my love. / I will race like a child through the fields, / I will chase off the unkindness of ravens. / My words will grow thick as marshes, / sheltering nests in salty steams.” The poems in Section II are some of the most beautiful and moving poems in this collection. See especially “Tenebrae” (pg. 21), a plea for life; “Poise” (pg. 26), a rant against giving in to cancer; “Snow White” (pg. 30), a poem of mourning for self and others; and “Four Prayers for Forgiveness” (pg. 34-35), a poem that turns illness into beauty: “–the scattered lumps in my lungs / become church domes roofed in green mosaics, / my bones’ fissures fill in with grass-green yarn. / . . . I open my eyes and all is golden.” 

Section III seems to present a corrective reaction to the joy expressed in the final poem in Section II. The poems in this last section are short, mostly one stanza, a catalog of things that are broken, cracked, ripped, or chipped. The warning that nothing lasts forever is implied in poems such as “Partings” (pg. 44) and “Woman with a Hole in Her Stocking” (pg. 45), in “Red Never Lasts” (pg. 47) and “Autumn” (pg. 57). Yet, as always in Silver’s poems, the warning is tempered by the beauty of her words and the depth of her insight into what it is to suffer over the course of an illness that has remissions and recurrences, that sees the body changed and relationships altered. In “Ideal Speech” (pg. 58), she writes “Listen to the Holy Ghost. She blows through you, / she blows her poems right through you.” Even when days seem darkest, the ideal speech for Silver is poetry, and she is the “you” through which the Holy Ghost speaks these auricles. In the book’s final poem, “Three Roses” (pg. 59), the author once again works her spell, turning illness into beauty and despair into hope. “Where only my scar line remains, a red rose blooms. / Luscious, full, so open that if it dropped a single petal, / it would not be as lovely as it is this very moment.” And in the poem’s final lines, “Lay her hands on my chest–here, I give it to you. / Feel your palm on my skin heat and spark,” What is the “it” she gives us? I believe that Silver invites us, as Whitman did, to merge with her and to live within her words, which are her flesh, the poems she writes and then gives us to read and ponder.  

Miscellaneous 

In my annotation of Silver’s second collection, “I Watched You Disappear,” I wrote that her poems might be difficult for some to read: “These poems are beautifully crafted, often primal, and they touch the deepest reaches of personal illness and the shadow of mortality. Readers who have breast cancer or who have family or friends living with breast cancer, might find these poems difficult to read–others under the same circumstances might find them difficult and yet, at the same time, essential.” The poems in this collection can be as raw as they are hauntingly beautiful. But, as do her other books, this one again opens to us a world apart, one we cannot enter unless we share this author’s diagnosis and illness trajectory. If we are caregivers or care receivers, if we suffer or we watch loved ones suffer, these poems plunge us into emotions that we ignore at our peril.  

Publisher Louisiana State University Press 
Place Published Baton Rouge 
Edition 2016 
Page Count 65 

A previous version of this review was published in the NYU Literature, Arts, and Medicine Database. 
Web image created by Medhum.org

Susan Sontag has said, “Illness is the night-side of life, a more onerous citizenship. Everyone who is born holds dual citizenship in the kingdom of the well and in the kingdom of the sick.” Author Lina Meruane challenges the idea that people with illnesses are necessarily separated into a different kingdom than those who are not sick, asserting instead that illness can be part of anyone’s normality. She makes this case through her novel, Nervous System. The novel tells the stories of four family members and a boyfriend who, at one time or another, develop a serious illness or help take care of one of the others with a serious illness: it’s all illness, it’s all the time, it’s normal. We talk with Dr. Meruane about her idea of illness as normality as she presented it in the novel, and about how its atypical structure and its evocative and memorable prose contribute to the stories told and the ideas offered.

Co-host

Daniel Albrant

Source
Nervous System by Lina Meruane, translated by Meghan McDowell, Graywolf Press, 2021.

Links
–Lina Meruane’s bio
–Russell Teagarden’s blog piece about the novel, Nervous System, and his blog piece about the MRI scene in the novel.
–Russell Teagarden’s blog piece about Lina Meruane’s novel, Seeing Red.
–Video conversation between Lina Meruane and Meghan McDowell about Nervous System.
–Interview with Lina Meruane in LALT magazine about Nervous System.

A big thanks to Lina Meruane for sharing her thoughts on illness as normality and her writing processes.

The Clinic & The Person is a podcast developed by our editor Russell Teagarden to summon or quicken the attention of health care professionals, their educators, researchers and others to the interests and plights of people with specific health problems aided through knowledge and perspectives the humanities provide.

Web image by Medhum.org

In Sophocles’s Oedipus Rex, a plague ravages Thebes as divine punishment for an unpunished crime—the murder of the eponymous king’s predecessor.

Two and a half millennia later, illness remains a metaphor in Robert Icke’s buzzy retelling of the Freud-genic tragedy, now on Broadway after a West End run last fall. Susan Sontag, who cautioned that portraying disease as a symbol of social decay can stigmatize patients, would likely disapprove. (Perhaps, apotheosized on Mount Olympus, she cursed Lesley Manville, who plays Oedipus’s wife and—spoiler alert—mother Jocasta, with an illness; Denise Cormier filled in when I saw the production.)

At curtain rise, on a stage-wide video screen, Oedipus (a charismatic and commanding Mark Strong)—reimagined as a politician on the cusp of electoral victory—tells a throng of eager reporters and supporters: “The civic body is ill. And that isn’t… chemicals in lakes—it’s us; we’re sick… The water got poisoned, and we got used to the taste.”

Economic inequality and xenophobia abound, as do rumors surrounding the death of Laius, the former ruler and Jocasta’s former husband. And so Oedipus promises to open an investigation. This off-script announcement exasperates his campaign manager and brother-in-law Creon (John Carroll Lynch), but Oedipus is steadfast in determining what happened. In Icke’s adaptation, probing the metaphorical plague is less a divine mandate and more a political act of narrative control. And, as Oedipus doubles down on transparency, what he uncovers about a fateful crossroads unravels his sense of self.

The truth of Oedipus’s identity is old news for most viewers, and we know that he is going to win. Yet Hildegard Bechtler’s set—an office with a hodgepodge of furniture, TV screens, and a clock counting down until the release of the election results—cultivates a palpable sense of uncertainty.

The successful set embodies Mikhail Bakhtin’s notion of the chronotope, or the inextricable fusion of time and space in literature. The literary theorist cites the road as one example of a chronotope. Social divisions such as class, nationality, and religion collapse, and time unfolds unpredictably through chance encounters rather than routine.

In Oedipus, as election night comes to a close, movers strip the campaign headquarters bare, transforming the space into a chronotope that mirrors how our hero is stripped of everything he once believed about himself. The ticking clock heightens the temporal pressure, heralding the landslide victory while portending the inexorable revelation that Oedipus did what every little boy dreams: killed Dad and married Mom.

Bakhtin also argues that chronotopes allow abstract ideas about philosophy, society, and cause and effect—say, the limits of free will and the illusion of power—to “take on flesh and blood.” Oedipus highlights the vital role chronotopes play in narratives, even if the coda transports us to the start of the campaign, undoing everything.

And even if much of the script doesn’t sparkle. For instance, Jocasta telling Oedipus “You’ll be the death of me” and calling him “baby boy” feels heavy-handed. Modern updates to Oedipus’s family dynamic have mixed success. The parts of adoptive mother Merope (Anne Reid) and daughter Antigone (Olivia Reis) are a welcome addition and expansion, respectively, bringing understated humor and wisdom. On the other hand, Icke casts one of Oedipus’s sons, Polyneices (James Wilbraham), as gay and the other, Eteocles (Jordan Scowen), as unfaithful. This framing raises an uneasy question: Are we meant to read queerness as a moral transgression on par with infidelity or incest? (Sontag, who was bisexual, probably wouldn’t be thrilled by this either.)

Icke’s greatest writing, however, is Jocasta’s hesitatingly revealed, harrowing backstory: She was only 13 when Laius raped her and forced her to abandon the resulting child. Jocasta recalls the delivery in visceral detail: the fluorescent lights of the hospital, the newborn Oedipus’s mucus-slick body. But she is denied the opportunity to share her traumatic account on her own terms; in his relentless quest for answers, Oedipus forces her long-hidden narrative, precipitating the discovery of their true relationship.

Narrative medicine emphasizes that this kind of listening can be destructive to both patient and listener. Indeed, Jocasta kills herself, and Oedipus gouges out his eyes with her heels. (Not very healing.)

Some narrative humility would have served Oedipus well. As Sayantani DasGupta writes, “narrative humility acknowledges that our patients’ stories are not objects that we can comprehend or master, but rather dynamic entities that we can approach and engage with, while simultaneously… engaging in constant self-evaluation and self-critique about issues such as our own role in the story.” With greater narrative humility, Oedipus might have better seen Jocasta—and himself.

Icke’s Oedipus teaches us that listening must be humble, ethical, and emotionally attuned; had it been so, perhaps the drama’s seemingly inevitable ending could have been averted.

Oedipus, through Feb. 8 at Studio 54 in New York; oedipustheplay.com.

Bakhtin, Mikhail. “Forms of Time and of the Chronotope in the Novel: Notes toward a Historical Poetics.” The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays by M.M. Bakhtin, edited by Michael Holquist, translated by Caryl Emerson and Michael Holquist, University of Texas Press, 1981, pp. 84-258.

DasGupta, Sayantani. “Narrative Humility.” The Lancet, vol. 371, no. 9617, 2008, pp. 980-981. thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736%2808%2960440-7/fulltext

Web image from Sonia Friedman Productions Limited.

A MacArthur Fellow and author of several acclaimed novels, Antrim has previously published a memoir of his upbringing with his alcoholic mother. In this new memoir, flashbacks of childhood neglect and chaos are juxtaposed with the present day as he takes the reader through the acute phase of his illness: a lengthy hospitalization, a course of ECT, discharge from the hospital, rehospitalization, and eventual stabilization.  

The author considers his condition to be suicide, noting that “depression is a concavity, a sloping downward and a return. Suicide, in my experience, is not that. I believe that suicide is a natural history, a disease process, not an act or a choice, a decision or a wish…I will refer to suicide, not depression” (pp. 14-15).   

The book ends on a hopeful note. After several relationships that might be described as codependent, Antrim meets his current partner, whom he marries. He sees the roof of his building through his window and remembers a certain Friday in April but is comforted by the sound of his wife playing Chopin and Bach on the piano.  

This is an exceptionally brave book. Antrim does not attempt to whitewash his situation in any way. Surely it is humiliating for someone so successful to acknowledge he has been utterly debilitated. He loses track of time. He gains weight and cannot fit into his clothes. His new book is released, but he is in no condition to help promote it. At first, he objects to being called psychotic but eventually it comes as a relief to know he is understood. One Friday in April will be inspirational to others who have suffered to see how an accomplished person is reduced to being allowed to use his razor only under strict supervision.   

At times Antrim touches on the link between mental illness and creativity. If he had hoped the cathartic exercise of writing about his childhood would have stopped his illness he learns otherwise: “Writing had not stopped my dying. (p. 80)” At another point, his friends joke that his diagnosis “might enhance my literary reputation” (p. 115). Finally, in one of the more poignant episodes in the book, Antrim gets a call from the novelist David Foster Wallace and is encouraged to undergo ECT. He has an excellent response to that treatment, but later learns that Wallace has hanged himself.  

While a diagnosis of psychotic depression fits best with the range of symptoms the author manifests, his point about suicide as a distinct disorder is well taken. In fact, the most recent edition of the DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual) took the major step of including Suicidal Behavior Disorder as a “condition for further study.” This corroborates the author’s experience and means that SBD might be included in a later edition. (see also https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyt.2020.499980/full)   

Those who are looking for an exposé or critique of the mental health system will not find it here. Antrim credits his psychiatrists and the hospital with helping him get through an unbearable time. One Friday in April is a book that will give reassurance to people who have endured suicidal thoughts that if they persist they will get better.  

Publisher W.W. Norton & Company 
Place Published New York 
Edition 2021 
Page Count 141 

Web image from Wikicommons
An earlier version of this review was published in the NYU Literature, Arts and Medicine Database 

After eighteen years of clinical practice, I think I’ve looked after somewhere between four and five thousand patients in total. Some patients I meet only a handful of times. Others I know like extended family. There are all types of patients: pleasant ones, well-behaved ones, as well as difficult ones that try my patience and of course, some that I’d rather forget.

Of course, most of my patients are Chinese immigrants and immigrating is a difficult business, not something to be undertaken by the faint of heart. New home. Often a new language. Usually a whole new culture. The immigrant experience means uprooting a person or a family from all that they are comfortable with and placing them in a strange and unfamiliar setting.

If being an immigrant is hard, then being an immigrant as a senior citizen is even harder. Try learning English for the first time when you’re in your sixties and seventies. Try going to the bank or dealing with a leaky faucet when you are a stranger in a foreign land. And yet, I’ve seen countless examples over the years of Chinese seniors starting over in Canada somewhere in their sixth or seventh decades. I often wonder. What is it that makes them want to start over yet again in their life? Is it simply that they want to be closer to their children and grandchildren who’ve come to Canada? Is there nobody left back in their home country? Do they really know what they are in for? Can anyone really be prepared for it?

In my own family, I’ve seen this process of elderly immigrants play out firsthand. Both of my grandmothers spent portions of their later years living with my parents in Toronto, with varying degrees of success. Through them, I witnessed just how difficult it could be to be an elderly Chinese immigrant in Toronto, which is probably, with its enormous Chinese population, already one of the most Chinese-friendly cities in the world outside of Asia. 

In Taipei, my grandmothers could walk outside in the mornings and bring back fresh produce and noodles from the market down the street in their respective neighborhoods. Never mind that the produce in the Food City and Miracle Food Mart of my childhood was nowhere near as a fresh or tasty as the food culled on the subtropical island of Taiwan: in Toronto, our family lived in the suburbs of Scarborough, and later North York, so my grandmothers could only visit a store if my father was free on the weekends to drive them.

Of course, my grandmothers couldn’t read or speak much English. In the era before cellular phones and Google maps, my parents taught them to navigate the Toronto subway system by memorizing the pattern of the coloured tiles at the individual subway stations, back when the city made a point of individualizing each station’s appearance. Dundas Station meant yellow coloured tiles. This was important because this way my grandmother knew which spot to get off if she wanted to find Chinatown.

My maternal grandmother abhorred Canada. Her complaints were plentiful: the produce didn’t taste fresh, the winter weather was too cold, it was too difficult to go places without a car and the language barrier was insurmountable. Ultimately, nothing about life here was as easy or as convenient for her as life in Taipei. At some point, she actually learned enough English to pass her Canadian citizenship exam. But years later, she defiantly informed me that she had returned all that knowledge back to her teachers. She had forgotten it all.

My paternal grandmother didn’t voice her complaints about Canada as much. Whether it was because she was more content, or simply because she tended to keep more to herself, I’m not sure what she ultimately thought about being a Chinese immigrant. But watching from afar as she spent the long months from spring to fall in our house (she always returned to Taiwan before it got too cold), living with my mom while my father was mostly out of the house, I couldn’t help but surmise that things weren’t really that easy. She didn’t learn much English, and save for her morning walk around the neighbourhood, she rarely ventured outside the house, preferring instead to spend most of her days watching satellite television from Taiwan. Living with grandchildren you don’t know very well, a son who is usually at work, and making nice with your daughter-in-law on a regular basis; this was another form of the Chinese Canadian immigrant experience.

This phenomenon, that of the frustrated elderly immigrant, is one that I’ve seen countless times in my medical practice. Flummoxed by a language they don’t understand, struggling to live under the roof of a son or daughter-in-law that they aren’t completely in sync with, and often tasked with the thankless job of babysitting little grandchildren for no pay, the immigrant elderly experience is fraught with trials and tribulations. And that is before real crises hit the family: a car accident, or a health situation, or worse. Crises are difficult enough when you are surrounded by your social safety net of familiar family and friends. But now, imagine being in an unfamiliar country when life unloads a crisis as it is wont to do. The examples are endless, but the end result is the same. Frustration, resentment, and ultimately regret. Why did we ever bother to come here?

Over the years, I’ve seen versions of it all. Disinterested adult children chauffeuring their elderly parents to doctor appointments, and those children then falling asleep in the chairs while their parents are describing their symptoms next to them. Other times, I’ve seen seniors get chastised verbally by their children when they try to ask me one question too many. I’ve treated elderly patients who got into physical altercations with their son-in-laws. And it goes both ways too: I’ve seen adult children come to me to request Prozac knowing that their mother-in-law will be arriving a month from now.

When I sat down to write this piece about elderly immigrants, I thought about which of my patients I really wanted to know more about. One couple, the Chens, immediately leapt into my mind. I’ve changed their names here to protect their privacy. 

On the surface, there’s nothing special about them. They’re an elderly Chinese couple, living in Toronto while their children live elsewhere. They aren’t particularly well off, and they spend their retirement doing typical Chinese immigrant senior citizen things: attending doctor visits, taking classes at the community centre, and so forth.

But dig past the surface, and they are unique. They’ve been married for over sixty years, and they are quite possibly the happiest, most resilient seniors I know. When things happen to them that would certainly derail others, they laugh about it, avoid blaming others and then move on. I’ve seen it happen in my office many times.

A few years back, Mr. Chen was struck by a car while crossing the street as a pedestrian, injuring his shoulder. For many patients, this would be a cue for initiating legal proceedings and a demand for compensation, as well as an endless stream of doctor visits and requests for pain medications. How did Mr. Chen handle it? He laughed it off, dismissed my question about “who was at fault” in the accident and recovered within a few months while doing some exercises with a physiotherapist.

Not too long after that, Mrs. Chen was found to have a slowly growing brain tumour. For many patients, this would be cause for anxiety, angst and even hysteria. But for Mrs. Chen, it was just another fact of life. She decided that in her mid-eighties, she didn’t need to risk surgery, and she’d continue to live day by day, even though the neurosurgeons thought that a more aggressive approach might improve her mortality and her quality of life, especially if her vision were to decline further. But they didn’t take into account that she was already fine with her quality of life and didn’t see the need to potentially upend things with surgical complications. Now, three years later, she’s remained the same, happy, laughing patient, who always makes a point to end our visits with a “good bye“ or ”thank you very much,” spoken in English that she learned in her English as a Second Language class.

Actually, I’ll correct what I said earlier. The Chens aren’t just the happiest seniors I know. They are quite possibly the happiest, most well-balanced people I know. What is the secret sauce of their happiness? That’s what I set out to find out. And that’s what I explained to them when I brought them into my office to be interviewed a few weeks ago.

This is their story.

The first thing to point out is that neither Mr. nor Mrs. Chen’s life was easy. If we suspected that part of the magic sauce of resilience is the ability to live a peacefully blissful existence in a Garden of Eden type environment, the Chens’ lives, dating back to their childhood, shows that this is not the case.

Mr. Chen was born in a small town in the province of Shanxi, in Northern China in 1937. At that time, China was at war, trying to stave off Japanese occupation, and so he grew up in an environment where war and violence were everywhere. In fact, the Japanese began bombing his town of Qixian three days before he was born. As a child, he watched as soldiers of all the different warring sides-the Communist People’s Liberation Army, the Nationalist Kuomintang, and the Japanese—took turns filing through the town’s lone major road. His father was a businessman who later made a name for himself selling tea and often had to travel. Mr. Chen remembered that for some years, he would see his father only once a year. Fortunately, their family avoided major mishaps during the war years, but he remembers seeing body bags piled up by the side of the road. When World War II ended and the occupation by Japan ended, he recalled seeing people dancing in the streets.

Meanwhile, Mrs. Chen was born in 1938 in Tianjin in Northern China, one out of four children. Her father was a businessman, and her mother was a housewife. During the war years, her family moved regularly, living at different times in Sichuan, then Nanjing, and finally in Shanghai.

She had some recollection of planes flying overhead while she lived in Shanghai, and that her mother didn’t want her to attend school for fear of violence. But for the most part though, she didn’t see much of the violence of war firsthand.

Of course, the cycle of war in China didn’t end when the Japanese occupation ended. After the Japanese departed, the Chinese Civil War between the communists and the Kuomintang promptly resumed and only ended with the Communist Party victorious in 1949.

By liberation day of that year, Mr. Chen’s father had moved the family to Beijing. He was now a sixth grade student and heard the horns and sirens announcing the liberation of China. 

He would go on to continue his education in Beijing, and it was here that he witnessed the Chinese Cultural Revolution taking place. He was a university student in Beijing by the time the Cultural Revolution reached full swing, but he kept his nose out of politics and was not much directly affected. By now, there were no more actual classes in university. As engineering students, they spent time working in factories. He even recalled how during the Great Leap Forward, the students busied themselves with trying to figure out how to make iron into steel at Mao Zedong’s behest.

Meanwhile, Mrs. Chen had studied to become a mechanical engineer. She was one of only three women studying computers at her university, Tianda in 1960. She went on to study in an engineering school and then became a professor from 1961 until her retirement in 1998, at the age of 60.

Spread out over almost two decades, the Chinese Cultural Revolution under Mao Zedong marked the complete upending of all societal norms. Scholars were vilified. Universities were closed. Anyone with links to bourgeois thinking or a questionable family background was blacklisted. Countless people lost their lives and countless more lost their livelihoods.

Mr. and Mrs. Chen’s experience through the Cultural Revolution was notable mostly in that they managed to remain apolitical. Academics came under siege during the Mao era, and intellectuals were frequent targets of Mao’s reforms. They knew that it was better to avoid political conflict than to get into the heat of it.

When asked how he managed to survive this, he admits that he wasn’t that bothered by the political crises that surrounded them. He learned mostly to keep his mouth shut and keep out of trouble.

Mrs. Chen, meanwhile, became a scribe during meetings during the Cultural Revolution. In fact, she points out that her propensity for smiling and laughter showed up even here, as people identified her during these meetings as the “one who was always giggling.” On a more serious note, she remembers colleagues of hers who died during the years of infighting, but like her husband, she avoided most political issues herself.

Of course, all my elderly patients from China are survivors of the Cultural Revolution in one way, shape or form. And of course, there is a survivorship bias here. I’m talking to survivors, those who not only lived through it, but those who lived through China’s gradual rebuild, through Tiananmen Square, through Deng Xiaoping, and now live through to be able to tell their tales as Chinese Canadian immigrants.

Of course, while China was engulfed by these years of political upheaval, the Chens moved on with their personal lives. They had already met as university students but really got to know each other better in their final year of university. They ended up matching positions in Beijing together in 1962 and have been together ever since.

The Chens have two daughters, both of whom are now successful computer engineers with graduate degrees from prestigious North American universities. Their grandchildren are also studying to become engineers as well.

When her children were small, the Chens were busy as young academics. They were fortunate that Mrs. Chen’s hours weren’t long. She only taught two to three classes a week. Furthermore, the university had a kindergarten on site, and her mother came to help look after the grandchildren so that they could continue to work.

When asked about parenting tips, Mrs. Chen points out that they’ve been asked this very question many times by their friends over the years: “Your daughters are both so successful. However did you manage to inspire them?” 

Mrs. Chen tells me that she believes in parenting by example. She and her husband were both academics, so books were always plentiful in the house, and the parents could always be found reading. So, in time, the children saw them doing this and became intellectually curious themselves. “Don’t yell and berate,” she informs me. “That style of parenting doesn’t work anyways.”

What is unique about Mr. and Mrs. Chen’s immigration story is that while they have lived in Toronto for more than fifteen years, their two daughters have never lived here. This was a result of curious circumstances, but of particular relevance to our discussion.

When they first decided to come to North America to be closer to their children, one of their daughters was still studying in Manitoba and the other was on Long Island. Toronto, they reasoned, was roughly equidistant between Long Island and Winnipeg, and so they settled here.

A few years in though, their daughter in Manitoba married a Dutch husband, and before long, she had relocated to Holland to be closer to his family. This meant that the Chens would no longer be equidistant between the two daughters.

Still, rather than hinder their immigration experience, the fact that neither of their children are nearby seems to have strengthened their immigrant experience and actually gets to the root of how the Chens have thrived in Toronto. The Chens have never been reliant on their children. They made a point on arriving in Canada, to seek out the local LINC (Language Instruction for Newcomers to Canada) program, and began attending English classes on a regular basis. With no children to take them around, they’ve learned to make use of public transit. She tells me about how many of her fellow seniors at the community centre are reliant on their children to get around in Toronto. “They’re miserable,” she says. “They can’t do anything without their children.”

In my experience, many Chinese immigrants, even younger ones, pay only lip service to these offerings. With the influx of Chinese immigrants to Canada, it is possible to carry on a passable existence here and almost never speak English. But the passable existence has limits. You can rely on using exclusively Chinese-speaking service providers only so much, and there’s certainly a limit to how much patience your own children will have for acting as your translators.

The Chens moved into an apartment building near a bustling shopping centre, replete with a neighbouring Chinese grocery store and a large population of Chinese seniors. This is a far cry from other seniors like my own grandparents, who often end up living with their children in the suburbs, trapped on suburban streets where the nearest community centre or grocery store can’t easily be accessed except by cars which they cannot drive.

Through their English classes, the Chens became connected to various local Chinese community groups. Mrs. Chen proudly recalls that this was where she was introduced to me, having been informed that there was a local family physician who spoke Mandarin and was accepting new patients.

When asked what her overall sense of her immigrant journey is, Mrs. Chen tells me that she is most grateful for how she is treated by people in the Canadian service industries. A case in point: earlier in the week prior to our interview, she had received a notification of an error in her tax return from Revenue Canada. She took it upon herself to call Revenue Canada herself, and explained to me that in Canada, if she tells the agent on the other end of the line that her English isn’t very good, the person will invariably slow down and cheerfully take their time helping answer her questions. She says that this is a level of personal attention that simply doesn’t exist in China and is one of the things she is most grateful for here.

I think back to my own experiences dealing with the service industry, from my cellular provider to Revenue Canada. I’ve experienced many feelings when dealing with these people, but gratitude has never been near the top of the list.

These days, when the Chens visit their children in the US or in Holland, things are pleasant. Both of their daughters married foreigners. One of their son-in laws is Dutch and the other is American. They describe their son-in laws as both being extra polite, and extremely attentive to their daughter’s needs. But of course they would describe them this way. It only makes sense for such a happy couple to be able to get along just fine with their son-in-laws.

After sitting and talking to the Chens, I took away several ideas from their story. It seems that a stressful childhood environment does not preclude being happy and balanced as an adult. 

But the most remarkable trait of this amazing couple that I have learned is their willingness to adopt a growth mindset. I wonder who taught them this? Certainly, they grew up long before terms like growth and fixed mindsets became common parlance. I wonder if this comes from their background as educators. How else can I explain their willingness to come to Toronto, a country in a strange land where they had no existing family members? How else can I understand their enthusiasm for learning English at an age when many elderly are convinced that an old dog can no longer learn new tricks?

From this growth mindset, comes the steadfast determination to look after themselves and remain independent from their children. They know they can look after themselves, and their children know it too. In this day and age of complicated intra-family dynamics, when the best-selling psychology book on Amazon is titled Children of Emotionally Immature Parents, I realize the Chens have somehow figured all this out and they didn’t need a self-help book to do it.

We model ourselves, whether consciously or not on the people around us. When I was younger, I imagined that my life as a senior probably would mean living like my grandmothers: a lot of sitting around, imbibing television shows while grumbling about how nothing is quite as good as it was in the good old days. But then I think about the Chens, and it makes me realize that we’re never really too old to reinvent ourselves, or too old to move to a new country, or even too old to learn a new language. All is possible, as long as we remember to smile and laugh.

Web image by  Li Lin.

Additional Chapters from A Chinese City Doctor’s Notebook

When Your Body Isn’t Yours 

01.12.26 661

From Tigers to Otaku

09.16.25 1501

The Happiest Couple

07.28.25 1262

The Things We Don’t Talk About When We Talk About Dying 

05.13.25 1839

One Patient, Two Systems 

02.24.25 2498