Historical fiction conjures up images of faraway lands, foreign cultures, distant times. But often history can provide an unexpectedly exotic backdrop even when the time and place seem within relatively close reach. In 1912, the state of Maine forced a small fishing community of Black and mixed race people to evacuate their homes on Malaga Island, a small inhospitable rock jutting out of the Atlantic Ocean close to the coastline. Several of the residents were confined to mental institutions against their will because of eugenics-inspired fears of incapacity related to generations of social isolation.
Paul Harding uses this disquieting episode as the basis for his latest novel, The Other Eden. Harding is the author of Tinkers, his debut novel which was published in 2009 by Bellevue Literary Press. That book was awarded the Pulitzer Prize, a unique achievement for a book that had been published well outside of the mainstream. His setting is called Apple Island, and the founders are Benjamin Honey, a freed slave, and his Irish wife Patience Raferty who arrive on the island in 1792. They survive a monstrous storm and flood in 1815 and together with a handful of families build a community that over the next 100 years is able to endure and thrive in the face of the harsh elements that confront them.
The descendants of the Honeys are the most prominent characters in Harding’s narrative. The current matriarch, Esther, spends most of her time brooding in a rocking chair, keeping watch over her family, and vigilantly guarding a secret about her son, Eha. Eha is a carpenter, who partners with another resident on the island to build all of the homes for the residents; this partner is an older man who lives alone sheltered inside a hollowed-out tree and who has carved an intricate circular mural that coils upward along the trunk of his home. Ethan, Eha’s 15-year old son, is a precociously talented artist who is alert to nature and his surroundings and constantly putting images to paper. His two younger sisters are always on the go and playing with the children of three other families.
The outside world intervenes in this quiet secluded world when a team of officials from the neighboring town of Foxden on the coast comes to Apple Island with a mission — to investigate the health and well-being of the inhabitants. They are primed by an entrenched belief that there are certain people in society who are innately better and the consequent dangers of mixing races and inbreeding over several generations. With this in mind, the town representatives conclude that it is in the best interest of all concerned to condemn the Apple Island village and disperse its inhabitants. This is the only solution that they believe will prevent future generations from being adversely affected by the downward spiral of human intellectual and moral capacity and that will avoid the spread of this social contagion beyond the confines of the island. Interwoven with this depressing storyline, there is an effort by a local minister to rescue Ethan from Apple Island because he is very fair-skinned. He may be able to pass as White and his artistic talent may enable him to overcome his “flawed” racial beginnings. Needless to say, the path to a tragic ending is patiently laid out by the author. But Harding’s genius is to make us appreciate the deep humanity and abiding love that the inhabitants of Apple Island sustain even though they cannot escape the colony’s ultimate demise.
A plot summary cannot do justice to the beauty and power of Harding’s prose. His principal characters are simple people living a subsistence existence. But they are embedded in a lushly evoked environment, and they are attuned to the rhythms of nature and the cycles of daily human life. The emotions are deeply felt, and the action rings true; the inhabitants of the island are not cardboard heroes or angels. There is a threat of violence lurking just below the surface that can emerge with shattering force when triggered by unexpected events.
Ethan’s story is presented as a complex mixture of personalities and motivations. The minister who comes to Apple Island to tutor the children and who devises the plan to rescue Ethan from life on the island recognizes the remarkable native intelligence of his school-age pupils, one who is literate in Latin, another who has mastered geometry. But he painfully admits in his private journal to deep feelings of revulsion when he is surrounded by the black and mixed race children in school. When Ethan is relocated to the home of a wealthy family on the mainland to continue his art education, he becomes more than friends with one of the servant girls, Bridget. There is a familiar element to their story, but the last stage is surprising and moving in its depiction of devotion and steadfastness in the face of love and separation. Ethan’s fate is mysterious, but his drawings live on in museum exhibitions.
The underlying motivations of the mainlanders who come to survey the living conditions of the people on Apple Island are clothed in their seemingly noble aspiration of improving the lot of humanity. They use the language of social Darwinism to defend their eugenics agenda, and this is no simple literary plotline. The eugenics movement in the United States was widespread and widely accepted; the nation became obsessed with the concept of “fitter families” and the dangers of reproduction of the unfit, and over 60,000 “feeble minded” individuals were involuntarily sterilized in early twentieth century America. The horrible consequences of flawed science and mistaken beliefs about biology and intrinsic human worth are made abundantly clear. But Harding’s writing rises above formulaic condemnation or pedantic instruction to the reader. He makes you live the experience and the suffering of the islanders whose humanity is so grossly ignored by the team of experts sent to learn about them and then deal with them.
Many reviewers of The Other Eden have commented on the mythic nature of the book. I think they sell Harding short. I think his accomplishment is far greater. His writing is almost Biblical in nature, in the sense that Marilynne Robinson describes biblical writing in her recent book Understanding Genesis (Farrar, Strauss, and Giroux, 2024). In that work, Robinson marvels at how all of the events that unfold in Genesis occur under divine guidance and plans, yet the men and women maintain their independence to act and influence their fate. God and humankind are in a covenantal relationship. Each has the capacity to surprise, to rise above their circumstances, defy expectations and even act out of love and forbearance when circumstances might dictate revenge and retribution. Similarly, Harding’s literary world is infused with the powerful belief in human agency and decency, concepts in direct counterpoint to the biologic determinism to which the mainlanders subscribe
The Other Eden evokes many Biblical narratives and themes. Apple Island grows out of a flood and the inhabitants are dispersed after the decision is made to end the colony. There is demonic evil and the threat of servitude, with the image of an enslaving Pharaoh lurking over the heads of the investigators from Foxden. There is branding at birth, deception of elders, scheming to save a favored child, and banishment of a disgraced woman. Noah, Abraham, Jacob, Moses, Pharoah, and Ruth are hovering over the residents of Apple Island. Harding uses all of these archetypal tropes and personalities. But like all good Biblical narratives, the images serve to construct a human world that speaks to all of us. The Other Eden is more than a foundation myth. It is a chronicle of living.
THIS OTHER EDEN
Paul Harding
W.W. Norton and Co.
2023
221 pp (paperback)
Web Photo by Seth Dewey
