The Sick Child

The sick child is thought to be the artist’s sister. She is not a child but rather a young girl who is lying down or seated, with a blanket over her lower body and she faces a woman who is seated beside her, clutching the child’s left hand. We cannot see the woman’s face – it is turned down as she is bent over in apparent grief. While the painting’s title names the girl as the subject of the painting, it is the grieving woman and her attention to the girl that is particularly striking.

Death and the Child

Death and the Child depicts the anguish of a child who has been confronted with the corpse of her mother lying in bed. The child faces the viewer, hands pressing against her ears – she cannot bear to “hear”/ absorb what she has encountered; her face has an expression of fear and despair

Death in the Sickroom

In Death in the Sickroom several adults are scattered about, some standing, one woman sitting in the foreground; behind her another woman stands facing us. In the back of the room a figure sits on a chair, a blanket draped over her lap – presumably this is Munch’s sister. With his back to the wall an elderly man has both hands pressed to his chest. These individuals have come to help and mourn but they are isolated from each other, which adds to the grimness of the scene.

Image credits: wiki commons

Painting with Empathy: The Expressionist Art of Edvard Munch with Curator Øystein Ustvedt

Russell Teagarden 12.28.23 1787

Edvard Munch’s emotional portrayal of illness and suffering offers profound insights for health professionals and…

Tooker depicted waiting for a more specifically governmental bureaucracy in his painting, “The Government Bureau.” In that painting, the waiting people are reproduced several times to emphasize their anonymity, and the multiple bureaucrats peer out from frosted windows with only their eyes and noses visible — bringing to mind the concept of the “medical gaze” promulgated by the French philosopher,  Michel Foucault.

In another Tooker painting, “Ward,” he renders patients’ anonymity and a sense of abandonment in the hospital setting–with government bureaucracy invoked by the American flags hanging on the wall.

Image Credit
The Waiting Room, George Tooker, 1959. Collection of the Smithsonian American Art Museum. Image used for educational and critical commentary purposes.

George Tooker documentary videos from Columbus Museum

The house sits at the foot of a spring-green mountain, painted over with long cascading strokes of darker green, giving the impression of a verdant and peaceful setting. Contrast this to the brown ridge where the figure is sitting, huddled in a long sleeve jacket, hands tucked into pockets. The ridge is barren except for a single tree that is mostly bare branches with sparse pale-pink leaves.

Matthew Wong was a rising young painter who died of suicide on October 2, 2019. In a moving obituary by the New York Times, his mother explained that Mr. Wong “was on the autism spectrum, had Tourette’s syndrome and had grappled with depression since childhood.” This helps to explain the sense of isolation and longing in the painting, depicted by the solitary figure on a barren ridge, looking back at a house in lush green surroundings. The figure also appears to be physically cold, wrapped in long sleeve coat, hands tucked in pockets, with no skin showing, but is sadly separated from shelter by an icy white distance. This dynamic, amidst a landscape of majestic mountain rising into star-crowded sky, gives a sense of melancholy beauty and loneliness.

The title of the painting, “See you on the Other Side,” can be interpreted in numerous ways. Mr. Wong is known for incorporating mythical elements into his work, so is this the beginning of the hero’s journey? If the tree in the foreground is interpreted as being laden with pale pink flower buds, there is a sense of hope and promise that the figure is leaving home and will return triumphant on the other side. But the tree can also be seen as a representation of fall transitioning into winter, hanging onto a few withered leaves, as the last bright red autumnal leaf blows away. Is the figure heading away from the verdant house and mountain into winter, the season that classically symbolizes death? Does the other side refer to an afterlife? A third interpretation to consider is that the figure is not leaving the house, but actually trying to get there. In this case, on the other side would refer to crossing the vast white expanse where no path is marked and no help is in sight.

View the painting at Museum of Fine Arts Boston ➔

Matthew Wong’s Biography: www.matthewwongfoundation.org/biography
A previous version of this review was published in the NYU Literature, Arts, and Medicine Database.
Web image from www.matthewwongfoundation.org/

At age 18, Frida Kahlo suffered a catastrophic accident that had lifelong consequences. The school bus in which she was a passenger collided with a trolley. Her spinal column was broken in three places, as were her collarbone, two ribs, her right leg and foot. The treatment was to lie on her back for one month, enclosed in a plaster cast. In addition, Kahlo had polio as a child, and one leg was shorter and thinner than the other.

This stunning portrait demands the viewer’s attention. A woman, Frida Kahlo, looms in the foreground, central to the painting, facing the viewer fully frontal, a few tears spilling down her face. She is nude, except for a sheet that is wrapped around her foreshortened lower body, and the widely spaced straps of an upper-body corset. On the one hand, the figure is passive, gazing at us almost without expression, completely still, acceptant of the scattered nails and rigid column that penetrate her body. On the other hand, the beauty of her perfectly formed breasts and well-formed upper body, the eyes that engage the viewer, subtly convey the energy of the figure’s spirit and will. At this point in Kahlo’s life, the painful physical problems that had plagued her on and off for years were becoming unrelenting. Doctors prescribed a variety of orthopedic corsets to support her degenerating spine. The portrait seems to personify pain and simultaneously some level of tolerance for pain.

Many who view the painting are reminded of images of Christ on the cross. Kahlo was certainly long-suffering and represented the physical and emotional aspects of her condition in many of her works (for example, “Tree of Hope” and “Henry Ford Hospital“), but the energy and originality of her personality and artistic vision shine through. For interesting commentary on “The Broken Column,” see Hayden Herrera. Frida Kahlo: The Paintings (New York: Harper Perennial) 2002, pp. 180-183. Also useful is Gannit Ankori’s commentary in her book, Imaging Her Selves: Frida Kahlo’s Poetics of Identity and Fragmentation (Westport, Connecticut and London: Greenwood Press, 2002, pp. 114-119). Ankori points out that the vertical fissure of Kahlo’s body and the fissures in the earth surrounding her evoke violation — consistent with Kahlo’s statement that a metal rod had entered her hip and penetrated her vagina.

Web image from Wiki Commons

Dégas’ brilliant rendering of perspective pulls the viewer into the mystery of what has taken place in what appears to be a woman’s bedroom. At the foot of the single-width bed, a coat is thrown over the metal bedpost frame. In the right foreground a bearded man leans against a closed door. His shadow looms behind him, large against the door. His shadow is generated by the single small lamp set upon a small round table near the center of the room. On the floor next to the table lies a piece of cloth or clothing (said to be a corset, p.674 of reference below). 

Turned, bent away from the man, partially kneeling on the floor at the other side of the room, is a young woman whose left shoulder and upper back are bare. The short sleeve of her white dress (nightgown?) hangs off her shoulder. She clutches to her body a blanket or drape. In contrast to the man, who stands in semidarkness, the woman’s back is bathed in the light of the nearby lamp. 

Clothing strewn on the floor and the looming man posted against a door suggest an assault. Although early 20th century critics did indeed perceive the painting as depicting the aftermath of a rape, that interpretation is not a foregone conclusion. The Philadelphia Museum of Art notes that Dégas referred to this work as “my genre picture” (a picture showing everyday life). The museum states further that “an annotation in a notebook used by Degas in this period provides a clue as to his intentions: ‘Work a great deal on nocturnal effects, lamps, candles, etc. The fascinating thing is not always to show the source of light but rather its effect.’ ” For another discussion of this painting, see Body, Place, and Self in 19th-Century Painting, by Susan Sidlauskas (Cambridge University Press, 2000). 

Web image from wikicommons

In that drawing a mother leans back in her chair, surrounded by clamoring children who snuggle, kiss, pull at her. Clothing is scattered about – on the floor, on a basket. Several dogs lean toward the figures, adding to the domesticity of the scene. 

Web image from National Gallery of Art.

Japanese American artist Henry Sugimoto (1900-1990) depicted life in the Arkansas internment camps into which he and his entire family (including wife and child) and many others of Japanese descent were forced, following the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941. Sugimoto’s life and painting were profoundly influenced by his incarceration. His subjects changed from landscapes to scenes of camp life and the Japanese emigration/immigration experience; these works often had social and political purpose. This scene is bleak, almost colorless; the sky is cloudy. Barracks stretch on either side of a narrow road in repetitive monotony. Too lone figures are the only people in sight and the only vegetation detectable, besides marsh grass, is the sketchy outline of treetops in the distance. Sugimoto told an interviewer that he used to go to the edge of the camp and try to imagine the Arkansas landscape beyond. 

Nisei Babies in Concentration Camp

Children were born during the 1940s internment of Japanese Americans – life went on. Second generation Japanese (Nisei) who were U.S. citizens by law were incarcerated along with their parents. Perhaps the children in this picture are faceless because Americans were treating people of Japanese descent as one deindividualized and dehumanized entity, to be viewed with suspicion and distrust. This painting juxtaposes helpless infants with military might and barbed wire. Sugimoto uses the term, “concentration camp” in labeling the scene, while the U.S. government called them “relocation camps” (people were relocated from the West Coast to the U.S. interior).

Harsh Canvas: Henry Sugimoto

An earlier version of this review was published in the NYU Literature, Arts, and Medicine Database (Litmed).
Henry Sugimoto’s Self Portrait from Wiki Commons

The renowned English social realist and portrait painter, Luke Fildes (rhymes with “childs”), created The Doctor in 1891 after Henry Tate commissioned a painting from him for his new museum, the Tate Britain. The subject of the painting was Fildes’ choice. Despite a poor reception among art critics when it was first exhibited, the painting quickly became iconic as the physician ideal. Over its 133-year history, the painting has been used for a variety of purposes, including inspiration, education, propaganda, and politics. During that time, the ways in which the painting represents the physician ideal changed. We talk about these aspects of the painting with Hannah Darvin from Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario, Canada. She has conducted extensive research into the painting and its creator.

Links
Image of The Doctor from the Tate Britain Museum.
About Hannah Darvin at Queen’s University.
Hannah Darvin’s description of her research for the Harvey Cushing/John Hay Whitney Medical Library at Yale University.
John Brewer Eberly’s diptych rendering a modern version of The Doctor in which computer technology is interjected between doctor and patient. 

Feature image from Wikicommon

Cold Eye, Warm Heart: Medicine and Anton Chekhov  

Jack Coulehan Aug 6, 2025

A moving portrait of Anton Chekhov, whose dual life as physician and writer reveals the deep interplay between healing and storytelling.

One of the most successful patient-artists was Auguste Forestier, hospitalized at Saint-Alban at the age of 27 after placing pebbles on a train track and causing a train to derail.  After his discharge from treatment, Forestier remained at Saint-Alban for the rest of his life, where he worked in the kitchen. He began to create toys for the children of hospital employees using discarded materials, even butcher’s bones.  In this exhibition we see not only a boat created by Forestier from scraps of wood but also a print of Tosquelles proudly holding up one of Forestier’s boats.  

The work of Saint-Alban artists came to the attention of French artist Jean Dubuffet, who, after reading the 1922 book Art of the Insane, had founded the Art Brut (also known as Outsider Art) movement.  Dubuffet’s attempts to collect it were at first greeted with skepticism by Tosquelles.  However, the success of Forestier (eventually he even came to the attention of Picasso) was such that the profits from his work were used to help fund the hospital.   

At its previous venues in Europe (the show originated in Barcelona) a larger number of pieces from Saint-Alban were displayed.  At its US venue, the show has been augmented with work from American asylums, which prove to be a highlight of the exhibition.  Even without a Tosquelles to inspire them, these patients created beautiful and fascinating art.  

We see, for example, a coat made by Myrllen, a schizophrenic patient from Tennessee.  The patient had reportedly worsened in response to such few treatments as were available at the time.  In desperation, she was given discarded rags and threads.  What she produced gives us a window into her condition, with strange words and figures whose meaning was known only to her.  Ironically, after making several such pieces the patient lost her creative impulse and stopped sewing once put on Thorazine, the first antipsychotic medication.   

Another piece, a watercolor entitled “An Antarctic Scenery,” is one of the earliest known American asylum paintings (c. 1816).  The patient-artist, Richard Nisbett, in his paranoid imagination has chosen to depict “a fleet of murtherous Pirates” invading Antarctica. Nisbett was a patient at Pennsylvania Hospital in Philadelphia under the treatment of none other than Benjamin Rush, often considered to be the father of American psychiatry.  

Although the exhibition closes in August, a book (which will be for sale at the Museum and online) is expected to be released in November 2024.  The link to a virtual conversation with the show’s curators is given here:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s9j3fMn0xJA (1 hour 19 minutes).

Francesc Tosquelles is frequently mentioned in The Rebel’s Clinic, by Adam Shatz,  a recent biography of the psychiatrist, Frantz Fanon.

A Tosquelles Glossary from the Barcelona exhibition is also a helpful tool: https://www.cccb.org/en/exhibitions/guide/francesc-tosquelles/237849 

Illustrations: 

Auguste Forestier (1887–1958, France) Untitled (Boat), 1935–1949, Wood, fabric, metal, leather, nail, 29 1/2 x 45 1/4 x 9 1/2 in. Centre Pompidou, Paris, Musée national d’art moderne/Centre de création industrielle, ART BRUT/Gift of Bruno Decharme in 2021, AM 2022-43. 

Romain Vigouroux (active mid-20th century, France), Francesc Tosquelles on the Roof of a Building at the Saint-Alban Psychiatric Hospital, Holding a Sculpture by Auguste Forestier, 1947, Gelatin silver print, 7 x 4 7/8 in Collection Family Ou-Rabah Tosquelles. 

Richard Nisbett (1753 England-1823, United States) An Antarctic Scenery, 1816, watercolor.  Collection of The Library Company of Philadelphia.  

American Folk Art Museum  
Lincoln Square, New York, NY 10023
Folkartmuseum.org

We explore two paintings, each rendering one of two different perspectives on tuberculosis (TB). We first take a close look at Alice Neel’s 1940 painting, T.B. Harlem, and focus on how it depicts the suffering and destruction TB caused, and reveals some of the social determinants of TB at the time. We then examine Thomas Lawrence’s 1794 painting, Portrait of Catherine Rebecca Grey, Lady Manners, and work through how it conveys the convergence of TB clinical manifestations with beauty ideals at the time.

Links:
Here are the links for the paintings we discuss:
T.B. Harlem, Alice Neel, 1940, oil on canvas
Portrait of Catherine Rebecca Grey, Lady Manners, Thomas Lawrence (1794), oil on canvas
The Sick Child, Edvard Munch, 1907, oil on canvas 

Background sources:
JAMA issue featuring cover with Alice Neel painting, T.B. Harlem, and William Barclay commentary.
Russell Teagarden’s According to the Arts blog piece on T.B. Harlem.
Hoban P. Alice Neel: The Art of Not Sitting Pretty. New York, St. Martin’s Press, 2010. Day, C. Consumptive Chic. London, Bloomsbury Visual Art; 2017, 189 pages.
Russell Teagarden’s According to the Arts blog piece on Carolyn Day’s book, Consumptive Chic.
Day C, Rauser A. Thomas Lawrence’s Consumptive Chic: Reinterpreting Lady Manners’s Hectic Flush in 1794, Eighteenth-Century Studies, vol. 49, no. 4 (2016) pp. 455–74. (Not open access)
Russell Teagarden’s According to the Arts blog pieces on The Sick Child, and on Munch’s approach to his painting, and podcast episode with Øystein Ustvedt, curator and Munch expert on Munch’s paintings rendering illness, suffering, and grief.
Here’s an image representative of the 1990s fashion trend known as “Heroin Chic” that we referred to during the podcast.

The Clinic & The Person is a podcast developed by our editor Russell Teagarden to summon or quicken the attention of health care professionals, their educators, researchers and others to the interests and plights of people with specific health problems aided through knowledge and perspectives the humanities provide.

Feature image by Bia W. A.